Sewing the rectum lying-in woman changes to sue midwife's unauthorized operation Doctors and patients' dispute fall into one more pair of and fail

Sewing the rectum lying-in woman changes to sue midwife's unauthorized operation Doctors and patients' dispute fall into one more pair of and fail
Sewing the rectum lying-in woman changes to sue midwife's unauthorized operation Doctors and patients' dispute fall into one more pair of and fail
The reputation infringes in the lawsuit Chen Cheng is sentenced to lose a lawsuit. So far in July of 2010, the time of 16 months has already passed by. Not long, but can change a lot. Such as Shenzhen " Sew the rectum " Incident: A lucky honour of midwife accused of sewing lying-in woman's rectum, has gained the lawsuit of infringing of the reputation, the court judges that there is no evidence to make it known at that time a lucky honour was sewn to get on lying-in woman's forest quiet(assumed name) Rectum,Lin husband at Jing Cheng Chen (assumed name) Need to apologize for this and sustain economic losses; Lose the husband and wife of the lawsuit, in the lawsuit brought after slightly, are no longer entangled with being sewn the rectum to pitch, then investigate whether a lucky honour is the out-of-range operation. Have much a dramatic one this " Reverse " Come quietly, but repeated the destiny contours of dispute of several doctors and patients quite beneath mention instantly - -Because disease side occupies the respect to exist in the professional knowledge insufficiently, produce understanding and offset to the treatment means which the hospital adopts, and then once " The shocking billow " Blow against one's face The background is, the instantly deeply worried relationship between doctors and patients. " sew the rectum " Incident retrospect July 23, 2010: Chen Cheng is sewn the rectum while suspecting wife Lin Jing's production, then release news to the media. " sew the rectum " The incident initiates the great disturbance. July 30, 2010: Shenzhen defends people's committee and notifies the investigation result, claims to have no evidence to prove a midwife sews and closes lying-in woman's rectum. August of 2010: The police in Shenzhen announce that appraise the opinion book. August of 2010: A lucky honour of midwife pushes Chen Cheng and two medias to the defendant's seat. October 18, 2011: The lying-in woman Ms. Lin lodges a complaint against midwife and hospital. Three " innocent conclusions " Lawyer Deng Hui says, a lucky honour is in good condition at present, because " the lawsuit has been won, do not have psychological burden " . Zhang JiRong, 46 years old, narrate the midwifery experience, midwife of gynaecology and obstetrics of the hospital Shenzhen phoenix for 20 years, the thing receives the treatment leaving the post and checking and studying that the hospital made promptly soon after taking place. At the night of October 21, a lucky honour of connection that the reporter has attempted, but it was a 11 -year-old son that answered the mobile phone, "mother has gone out, does not know where to go. " The son of one says. Deng Hui says, Zhang JiRong stills have resentment to the media at present. Deng is the attorney of one. At the beginning of this year, a copy of pleadings of Zhang JiRong will be informed oldly and sincerely to the district people's court of Lo Wu of Shenzhen, and win in this honorary right dispute lawsuit. The court verdict that the district people's court of Lo Wu assigns reveals, the court thinks hygiene and population Family Planning Commission of Shenzhen (call Shenzhen in the following text and " defend people's committee " ,Reporter's note) The survey report made after the thing takes place, " provide after carrying on the detailed investigation to the incident, the investigator has relevant professional knowledge, the procedure investigating also accords with the legal provision, content its, until qualification that public security organ provide identical in opinion book later, can regard as, assert the intersection of case and basis of fact. According to asserting, evidence does not indicate the plaintiff has fact which sews up lying-in woman's rectum of the above-mentioned survey report, so the defendant advocates the fact of the stitch lying-in woman's rectum that the plaintiff implemented, our institute refuses to assert. " This " sews the rectum " After happening, third " innocent conclusion " which the official organization draws . According to this, the court asserts Chen Cheng's reputation tort is established, requires Chen Cheng to apologize and compensate for a lucky honour spirit and damage and conciliate 30000 yuan of gold. First " innocent conclusion " Defended people's committee to make on July 30, 2010 by Shenzhen. In this survey report, Shenzhen defends people's committee to think: Evidence does not indicate lying-in woman's rectum is sewn up. Because can not accept Shenzhen defended the investigation conclusion that people can appoint, Chen Cheng reported a case to police immediately. On August 12, 2010, police will obtain and appraise the opinion: The lying-in woman sees ring pile deviate from around rectum, edema. Deviate from the thing in 9 position, it is obvious black silk thread is sewn and pitched. It is expressed when being interviewed by media that the domestic largest medical speciality is exchanged to cloves person in charge of garden website Li TianTian of the platform, this means lying-in woman's rectum has not been sewn. Encyclopaedia of one hundred degrees reveals, should exchange the platform and inherit " independence, non-commercial, pure academy " Exchange idea. Li TianTian is more willing to believe Zhang JiRong " lying-in woman's haemorrhoids bleed, oppression arrests blood invalid, satisfy the ligature haemorrhoids core " Statement,because from saying whether last lying-in woman the possibilities of the rectums on sewing on operations gynecological. Vice Chief of Guangdong Province department of public health Liao XinBo thinks, this incident and " 8 mao cure the disease at 100,000 yuan " Similar, exist and exaggerate and unfounded, " force (give) together The incident shame of the medical circle " . It is said correctly that a relatively wide network card spreads at the ends of the earth " Sew the rectum " With understand. This net card thinks, Shenzhen " sews the rectum " Have obscured " Totally close the rectum " With " stitch (or ligature) Rectum haemorrhoids bleed and click " Difference. In the view of common people, " sew the rectum " "to covert payment sew up to close rectum,it is pull out dung not to let by you! " In doctors' view, so-called " sew the rectum " " perhaps because the pressure is too big in the abdominal cavity at the time of production, causes haemorrhoids to bleed, in order to meet an urgent need temporarily, the midwife sews up (or ligature) Haemorrhoids bleeding order. " "If retaliate by sewing up the way to close patient's rectum, does not accord with basic logic, even if the criminal, will neither reach the crazy intensity of perishing together, nor be in revenge way that will be found on this stud. " The network card is spoken. Change quietly too tall and erect and smallly and hardworkingly to approve the judgement once. "This case is very ridiculous to the understanding that sews the rectum. " It is a law professor of the hygiene of Beijing University of Trad. Chinese Medicine, the famous medical dispute case law expert in the industry to be tall and erect. Another of him value identity, forest quiet to tell JiRong and the intersection of Shenzhen and the intersection of phoenix and the intersection of hospital and the intersection of medical treatment and agent of damaging case Zhang. After losing a lawsuit in dispute case of the reputation, the forest is quiet on April 20 this year, on the grounds that medical treatment is damaged, have submitted indictments to court: Require judgement Zhang JiRong and phoenix's hospital of the court to compensate for more than 200,000 yuan for every loss, and make an apology publicly. The indictment that Chen Cheng offered this newspaper reveals, the thing has changed quietly: Though incident reason arises " The lying-in woman is sewn the upper rectum by the midwife " ,But not appeared in the indictment " Sew the rectum " Wording,last " plaintiff (Jing Lin, reporter note) ' haemorrhoids operation ' that is done without authorization because of defendant Zhang JiRong causes the anus to be sewn and pitched in week " . It seems tall and erect and smallly and hardworkingly that because doctors and patients occupy the respect in the professional knowledge to have enormous differences, state and offset and can be understood before Chen Cheng. "To not understanding medical knowledge, does not understand the ordinary people whose rectum dissects the structure say, the rational conjecture is certainly that the rectum has been sewn. For ordinary people, it is extraordinary Normal. " "Before the medical incident was not made clear, Mr. Chen's statement is the statement relying on one's own understanding to make to the media. Shenzhen " Defend people's committee " After asserting, Mr. Chen has not called sewing the rectum firmly, has not infringed maliciously. " Therefore, Zhuo XiaoQin thinks, what the court made is misjudge. But lying-in woman square decision pester herein no longer, then until " the out-of-range operation leads to the fact the injury " Bring a suit before court. " regulation of medical organization " stipulates, the medical organization uses the technical staff of the hygiene to be engaged in health care beyond this speciality, do not a technical staff of the hygiene deal with according to using. "Zhang JiRong is that a midwife is not a doctor, can't do the thing that a doctor want to do. In addition, even if is anus intestines haemorrhoids, this is not but want to ask the anus intestines subject doctor to hold a consultation by the obstetrician, then confirm the healing solution. " Zhuo XiaoQin thinks, it is very normal that this kind of haemorrhoids appear on lying-in woman, do not belong to the emergency, "bleeding will stop quickly. Will not cause very serious consequence, should report to the obstetrician. " Compare the intersection of educational circles and expert, emphasize procedure, the intersection of Harbin and the intersection of children's hospital and early morning Li, surgeon of ambition, though think too " It is very important for doctor that the procedure is correct " ,But as clinical worker in first line, he entangled with until " whether procedure fruit important justice " more or less . "Correct procedure to let pieces of surgical doctor come on operation. Wait for several leave hour procedure let surgical doctor come, deal with, or how much do me a favor minute conveniently? It is rational to help, but this is a procedure mistake. " Interview by media, Li say, have the intersection of patient and facial many places sustain a slight injury to examine for example early morning, according to the regulation, should be responsible for sewing up several stitches of eye, ear, nose and throat respectively by ophthalmology department, ENT dept., stomatology department doctor separately, the doctor of stomatology department sews several stitches while healing up finally. Three subject doctors gather neatly, takes an hour most quickly. If by a stomatology department doctor " Conveniently " Sew up all wounds, need only 10 minutes - -After the dispute took place in this kind of situation, the patient sues the hospital, win accurately. This does not once have absolute winner's " The war " . Through this disturbance, Lin Jing has already been diagnosed that suffers from depression by the hospital, should " throw the child, and have suicidal inclination many times. " Because need to look after the wife, Chen Cheng can't already go out to work after the thing took place. Have narrated and received " The underworld " Harass, husband and wife have already moved twice. Moving for the first time, husband and wife move to " base 100 " of Beijing ,High building the most of Shenzhen. "Except avoid and harass, and want to give children a better environment to the wife. That is a top-grade community, I had some money at that time. " Five months later, Chen Cheng moves again, sits idle at home eating away a fortune as big as a mountain and makes them unable to continue affording the high rent. Now, Chen Cheng three people of one family rent in every month drawing rooms of room one one at 1100 yuan. Because " fear she throws down the child from the above " ,There is not a sofa in the room to hire out, there is no bed. Lin Jing and child are on the mattress on the ground of berth at ordinary times, Chen Cheng sleeps in the floor. "She cries everyday, can't be from sewing and come out in it. She who is optimistic in the past, the personalities all changed. " Chen Cheng says. " helpless act " two times Lie in the deep south hospital of phoenix of Shenzhen of No. 1062 East Road of Luohu District of Shenzhen, nowadays the gate has been closed already, have live. Several vans, minibuses park on the vacant lot in front of hospital. Solemn parking area of institute gate. On August 9, 2011, Shenzhen defended " reply regarding the hospital of phoenix of Shenzhen applies to stop doing business " by name that is published on the websites of person's committee to explain all these. " give a written reply " is called: Your institute (phoenix's hospital) The application material regarding the hospital of phoenix of Shenzhen suspends medical care filed is received. In view of the actual conditions of your institute, manage the relevant regulations of the regulation according to the medical organization, through studying, our committee agrees your institute stops doing business, the downtime is from August 8, 2011 to August 8, 2012. Before this, investor, hospital of phoenix, defend people's committee, refer to Shenzhen to the application of renaming as once also. After the former address opens a business again, " hospital of phoenix of Shenzhen " Will have passed out of existence, that will be replaced will be " Shenzhen Osman hospital of urology surgery " . The relevant person in charge of the school admits, this measure is really cannot help but. " sew the rectum " After the incident happens, go to disease that this institute seeks medical advice to sharply reduce, the prestige of the hospital is damaged seriously. Through this disturbance, how is this future of private hospital of starting afresh, nobody can answer at present. Remain undecided too, there is midwife's career of a lucky honour. "Fix on the basis of actual conditions and her personal will of the hospital. " In ask dishes of JiRong Zhang also will continue take office institute these, the answer that the relevant person in charge provides is not clear. (reporter learn, exceed Cao, build the people while being old)


|